This entry in the Guide to ALS will discuss troubling oral fluids (mucus, phlegm, and saliva) plus the equipment to remove the fluids. A different entry in this Guide: https://guidetoals.com/mucus-and-medications/ discusses troubling oral fluids and the medicines to treat them. (We also used a nebulizer in conjunction with medicines to thin out our son’s oral fluids, not remove the fluids, so a nebulizer is discussed here, while the medicines used in it are discussed in the entry cited above).
Oral fluids
First some definitions: There are mucus, phlegm, and saliva. Mucus is a slippery, gelatinous goo produced by your mucous membranes. It lines your mouth, nose, throat, sinuses, lungs, and gastrointestinal tract and it is necessary for the normal functioning of your body. Phlegm is the mucus secreted by the glands in the respiratory passages of the lungs. It is also called sputum. Saliva (commonly referred to as spit) is an extracellular fluid produced and secreted by salivary glands in the mouth.
From my experience caring for our son, his saliva was very runny and usually poured out of his mouth, whereas mucus was gooey and, over time, it changed to thick and rubbery and went down his windpipe and into his lungs. When excessive saliva and mucus first appeared in our son’s mouth, we got two machines through insurance to try to remove the stuff: a cough assist device and an aspirator (also known as a suction device). A doctor wrote prescriptions for the two machines and Millennium Respiratory Services, https://millenniumrespiratory.com, provided them. They had respiratory therapists on call all the time and they readily came to our house to adjust the machines to our son’s changing needs, also to test them, and to bring replacement parts. We found it extremely important that BOTH machines were always on and running when we had to suction fluids out of our son’s mouth. I’ll explain later in this text.
Cough Assist
I will discuss the cough assist device first. We had the Philips Cough Assist Mechanical Insufflator-Exsufflator T70. However, Philips Respironics stopped selling its respiratory care devices in the U.S. until it meets the demands of a consent decree from the FDA. Philips Respironics stated it will continue to support service and provide repair parts and accessories as long as they are available, but, in any event, not past October 1, 2028. The devices were discontinued due to contamination from breakdown of the foam insulation in the numerous devices. The breakdown products were getting into the breathing passageways and into the users. Our son passed away before the Philips Respironics device was recalled, so this device was the only one we used.
Here are two cough assist replacements for your consideration. (Our son never used these, so we have no experience with them):
The Synclara Cough System: https://www.hillrom.com/en/products/synclara-home-care-patient/
The BiWaze Cough System: https://abmrc.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/BiWaze-Cough-Brochure.pdf
Even though it’s discontinued, I’ll discuss the Philips device because I’m sure the other brands perform the same tasks the same way and may have the same pros and cons. The photo below shows a close up of the Philips without any attachments.

The photo below shows the device in use. A cough assist should also be running.

Note: An in-line filter should be present between the hose and the machine in the photo above; it is missing. The mask must be held firmly and uniformly against the mouth and nose to assure a good seal. Our son was too weak to use this machine by himself. The mask is not strapped to the face. Since our son’s facial and jaw muscles were very weak, whenever we pressed too hard, we pushed his lower jaw against his trachea and he began to choke, so we had to be very careful. If we didn’t press hard enough, the mask would not seal to his face, and the machine wouldn’t do its job. Sometimes the cough assist did its job so well that on Cycle Two (explained below) his lung fluids ended up in the mask and hose. The patient’s head must be either braced from behind with the caregiver’s hand, or better yet, against the headrest.
A minor annoyance with the Philips cough assist machine was that it automatically went into a rest mode if it idled too long, so many times when we were using the suction device, the cough assist shut down and we had to restart it.
Maintenance: You can wash the mask, but you should replace it frequently. Toss it if the inflatable cushion around the mask becomes brittle or won’t hold air pressure. The cushion will absorb facial oils and will decompose over time. You have to keep the cushion inflated to the patient’s comfort (not too hard; not too soft) by injecting air with a tiny air-filled syringe that should be provided. The masks should be covered by insurance, but insurance limits how many are allowed per month, so you may have to buy some yourself. The hoses, filters, and other parts are also replaceable, some more frequently than others. Don’t try to wash out the corrugated hose – you’ll never be able to clean every fold in the hose, plus, water will never drain from it, even if you shake it out and hang it up.
The cough assist functions through two cycles:
Cycle One (insufflation): This begins with a blast of air (positive pressure) being forced down the patient’s windpipe (NOT throat) into the lungs to get behind any mucus and gunk. The air must go down the windpipe into the lungs, NOT the esophagus into the stomach. There may be a physical problem if the patient’s stomach becomes distended.
Cycle Two (exsufflation): After a predetermined pause (set in the menu), we could hear a valve flip, so the machine began very rapidly sucking (negative pressure) all that air back out, and if we were lucky, any offending oral fluids from our son’s lungs. The negative pressure cycle was supposed to yank bodily fluids out. I said “Supposed to” because it was ALWAYS hit or miss. There was one big problem with the design: Imagine trying to vacuum a dusty room in your house by standing only in the doorway to that room, then aiming the vacuum wand into the room, and just waving it in the air and expecting it to suck out the dust (and any socks) from the floor. Yeah right. The room would still be dusty. From our experience, when the mucus in our son’s lungs was very thin and gooey (very early in his ALS journey), Cycle One would force air down into his lungs as expected, and Cycle Two would grab the gooey fluid fairly easily as the air was being sucked back out of his lungs. However, as the gooey fluid was coming up from his lungs and entered the back of his mouth, it would turn into a huge bubble that would burst inside his mouth while the mask was still in place, then the gooey fluid would coat his mouth, tongue, teeth, and most dangerously, seal off the whole back of his mouth with slime and prevent breathing. That was the scariest part. Once the ejector contacted the sheet of mucus, it pulled the whole sheet off his tongue or out of his throat like we were pulling a wet tablecloth off a table. It was disgusting. Since we always had the suction machine running, we quickly used that and sucked as much out as possible. We continued until he told us to stop, either because we succeeded, or because he was exhausted.
As our son’s ALS worsened, the mucus changed to very thick blobs, then even rubbery yellow lumps, and teaspoon-sized pieces that were more difficult for Cycle Two to grab and bring up to the back of his mouth. Cycle Two was almost useless for this very thick stuff because even though the blast of air in Cycle One got behind the blobs as the air was forced into his lungs, Cycle Two just pulled the air back out of his lungs, usually without any mucus and blobs.
Towards the end of our son’s life, the procedure became even more complicated, especially because of head drop. We needed two caregivers attending to him simultaneously. One caregiver had the cough assist turned on and running, plus that person had nearby a spray bottle of a saline solution for throat lubrication. We used Simply Saline (https://www.amazon.com/Simply-Saline-Adult-Nasal-Original/dp/B0013UU9WK). The other caregiver had the suction machine (aspirator) running plus had a flashlight on hand to see inside his mouth. I strongly recommend a small LED rechargeable flashlight, NOT the battery-operated kind. Many times, Cycle Two succeeded in bringing a large piece of rubbery mucus up, but only to the back of his mouth. Only sometimes we could grab it with the suction wand, but sometimes it slipped back down too quickly. I don’t know where the gunk went when it slipped back down (hopefully the throat and NOT the lungs). Because the gunk tended to clog the suction machine’s wands or ejectors, plus the tubing going to the suction device, we always had to have a cup of very hot water near us so we could dip the saliva ejector or wand into it under suction. The hot water loosened the gunk and allowed it to be sucked into the suction machine’s bleach-filled reservoir. The hot water was very effective.
At the end of Cycle Two, we quickly removed the mask, so we could inspect his mouth with the flashlight. Even just the act of removing the mask from our son’s face had to be timed perfectly because Cycle Two (the suction) kept the mask stuck to his face if the cycle hadn’t ended. By listening to the machine, we usually knew when to remove his mask.
If we could see with the flashlight that a rubbery piece had come up, the saliva ejector (or suction wand; discussed below) would be inserted quickly into his mouth to try to grab the piece before it slipped back down into either his throat or his lungs. Most of the time, any blobs that did come up were way in the back, so we had to be careful not to touch his uvula with the wand, because that could hurt him, or he would gag. As our son’s ALS worsened, we spent hours each session doing this. It was painful and usually unproductive. Another unpleasant occurrence during Cycle One: the positive pressure strongly inflated his cheeks, then Cycle Two caused his cheeks to collapse, so he usually bit his cheeks or his tongue or both. It was awful. Cycle Two also sucked some stuff out of his nose, so we also had to put a suction wand carefully up his nose to clean that out, too. I wish I had the suction device when I was a kid and had a stuffed nose. We have no idea whether the cough assist, or maybe the tracheostomy, caused one of his lungs to collapse. We found this out in late October 2021 just before he passed away.
Note: Millennium Respiratory Services loaned us a VOCSN device (ventilator, oxygen, cough, suction, nebulizer, https://www.venteclife.com) to try. See the VOCSN section below. It had 5 separate functions in one device, so we thought we would only need this one and return the cough assist and suction device, but we all disliked it after only 1 afternoon’s usage. When we tried out the VOCSN, we had to do one cough assist, then go to the VOCSN’s touch screen, switch to the suction function, then do the suction, then go back to the screen, switch back to the cough assist, etc. Too much time was wasted. Whenever we succeeded in getting a blob of mucus out of his throat, we didn’t want him to swallow it or go back into his lungs while we were switching functions. No go. We returned the VOCSN.
What we didn’t know regarding our son’s condition was that a lot of mucus had gone into his lungs. At the end of his life, he was taken to the ER for breathing difficulties and he was trached, but we found out that he had three major issues: he had a collapsed lung (I surmise it was from overly strenuous and aggressive use of the cough assist), one lung was infected, and one lung had mucus in it. He died of respiratory failure October 29, 2021.
Suction Machine (Aspirator), Suction Wands and Saliva Ejectors
Our son used a DeVilbiss Homecare suction unit, https://www.exmed.net/devilbiss-homecare-portable-suction-machine-unit, to remove saliva and mucus. See photo below. It and all the associated tubing, filters and Yankauer suction wands were obtained with a doctor’s prescription from Millennium Respiratory Services. All the parts and pieces were covered by insurance, but unfortunately, with limitations. The machine had a back-up battery, but it didn’t hold a charge for very long, so when we travelled, we had to be near a receptacle. Our van had an inverter, so we had 110 volt AC service for the suction machine and cough assist.
We had to travel with the aspirator many times for visits to clinics, doctors, and hospitals for our son. These places would not allow us to use it in the waiting rooms, so we had to find a back room or restroom first. Also, some of these places then had to quarantine that room and clean it after we were finished.
Some aspirator parts were replaceable only once a month under his insurance, and some parts were replaceable only once every 3 months. In the beginning of our using the suction machine with Yankauer wands (see description later on), the insurance company would only provide two Yankauers a month, but the Yankauers became gunked up and chewed up quickly (they were made of hard plastic and our son bit down hard on them and cracked them). The tubing also became gunked up. Note: The actual brands of tubing that Millennium sent us when we needed a resupply seemed to be different almost every time, so sometimes wands or ejectors fit easily into the ends of the tubing and other times not. The receptacle, or spittoon, as we called it, could be washed out, but it was thin plastic and cracked easily. If it was handled gently, it could last forever. The biological fluids collected in the spittoon were slimy, full of bacteria, and stunk badly. To overcome all this, we always added about 1 inch of water, plus a little bleach and detergent to the spittoon. The bleach killed the bacteria and odors, while the detergent helped wash out the slime. Whenever the tubing became gunked up, we sucked some very hot water through both the wand and the tubing into the spittoon. The hot water softened the slime and it washed out quickly. Remember to protect yourself from this stuff, too.

Aspirators, Suction Wands, Saliva Ejectors
Our suction device, or aspirator, came with disposable Yankauer suction wands (see photo below), but our son had a difficult and unpleasant time with them. Those were the only wands we knew about because they came with the aspirator. The Yankauers were made of hard plastic. Because of his involuntary bite, he bit down on them and cracked them.

The Yankauers are very long, are hard plastic, and came in 4 versions when we were using them: bulbed tips, non-bulbed tips, vented, and non-vented. A vacuum cleaner wand is usually vented the same way. Here’s a link to the bulbed ones we used:
The bulbed ones have holes or slots on the bulbs to prevent sucking in the patient’s cheeks and tongue while you’re aspirating the saliva and mucus. The holes and notches try to stop what similarly happens if you accidentally touch a vacuum cleaner wand to a curtain or a newspaper. The more holes in the bulb, the less suction at each point where contact was made. In our experience, the holes in the bulbs were so small that they could not suck up thick rubbery mucus. Besides suctioning our son’s mouth between his lower teeth and his cheeks, he always wanted us to force the bulb against his front bottom teeth to draw saliva over the tops of his front teeth and from his tongue area, but the tip kept slipping while we were exerting pressure and the wand went over his teeth and into his mouth. Our son also had a very strong involuntary bite and actually crushed many Yankauer tips. Insurance would only provide two per month, so we had to buy our own so we didn’t run out. Imagine having a bad cold, but only being allowed a few tissues per month.
Dentists also use suction equipment to remove saliva, water and other fluids from the patient’s mouth. While hunting on the web for alternatives to Yankauers, I discovered that the dental world called wands “saliva ejectors” or variations thereof, so ejectors didn’t appear during my initial Web searches for alternative wands.
My son’s dentist gave us the ejectors in the photo below to try out. The photo briefly mentions the problems.

I eventually found the two bent ejectors seen in the photo below. The green one was perfect for thick and rubbery mucus. The white one was best for thin runny mucus. There’s an even skinnier one than the white one and usually is blue, but I never tried it. Here’s an Ebay link: https://www.ebay.com/itm/355985659266.

For oral swabbing, cleaning, and subsequent removal of saliva, we used the Toothette Suction Swabs shown in the photo below connected to our suction machine. Here’s a URL to one supply site:
https://www.amazon.com/Toothette®-Single-Suction-System-Solution/dp/B005PT40QG
You can buy them with or without the peroxide packet.

You turn on the suction machine first. Then, before opening the outer envelope, you simply squeeze the peroxide pouch until it bursts and soaks the swabs, then you open the outer package, take out a wand, connect it to the suction machine, and swab the mouth without covering the side-vent hole. After swabbing, cover the side-vent hole with your finger, and the saliva and peroxide wash are sucked out. These didn’t replace what a toothbrush did. The green sponges at the tips were very easily torn. Our son didn’t like the peroxide taste in his mouth, so afterwords, we used a nice-tasting mouthwash, Biotene, https://www.amazon.com/Biotene-Fresh-Moisturizing-Mouthwash-Alcohol-Free/dp/B002KAOAZ4, which was not really for oral care.
We always needed both the green and white bent ejectors pictured above to be available at all times, regardless of the kind of saliva or mucus we found. We were constantly switching between the two by removing one of them from the tubing and inserting the other one. This wasted time and sometimes the ejector that was already in the tubing was slimy from mucus so the tubing wouldn’t hold onto the replacement. I solved this problem by installing a Teflon 3-way valve as shown in the photo below. The valve enabled me to connect two ejectors simultaneously, while only one was suctioning. The 3-way valve is a T-shaped connector. The red part in the photo could be turned to switch between the two bent adaptors. In the photo, the 3-way red valve is connected from the suction machine only to the ejector on the right (the ejector on the left is closed).

A schematic of the 3-way valve is shown in the drawing below.

SWIK oral suction device
I first became aware of this device in August 2023, after our son had passed away in 2021, so he never could have tried it. The SWIK is found at https://www.salivasystems.com. I wrote to them to get more information. The following are my own thoughts on this device. I never asked the cost of the device. The picture below shows the SWIK device itself.

The next picture shows the SWIK device in use.

One of the selling points is that the patient doesn’t need a caregiver constantly suctioning the mouth with a suction wand. The SWIK is placed behind the lower lip and in front of the lower teeth, and the tube is draped over one ear. I don’t know how the mouth could remain closed with such a bulky object there. An attached very thin tube is connected to a suction pump. In small print on the website, it was stated that no pump is included, so the ALS patient would have to acquire a suction device if it wasn’t already on hand. The user has to have the suction device running all day, unless it can be programmed to go off and on at regular intervals, or on demand. (Our suction machine was either on or off.) It will be noisy and the suction device will wear out fast if it is running all day. The SWIK device is supposed to be used for up to 12 hours, then discarded, so the user would have to have a constant supply of them. If a cough assist is needed, then the caregiver would have to remove the SWIK, use the cough assist, then reinstate the SWIK. Also, if the cough assist indeed succeeded in pulling mucus up from the lungs, then a suction device with a wand would be required to remove the blob from the mouth quickly before it slid back down into the lungs or stomach.
From my own experience at my dentist, my cheeks and my lips always cave in whenever the dentist wants to suction out oral fluids; he asks me to close my mouth around the suction tube. The SWIK company said caving in won’t happen with their device, but I’m a little skeptical about that. The suction on the patient’s machine can be adjusted to a weaker setting so that might decrease the chance of the cheeks and lips caving in. If the patient keeps his or her mouth slightly open, then the cheeks won’t cave in, but the mouth will dry out. The SWIK representative said their device has been tested to pull thick secretions, as heavy as molasses, as well as thin saliva. The suction level on the pump will aid in removing the thicker secretions as well. This device obviously would work for any secretions moving forward in the mouth. In our son’s case, a thick yellow coating of dried saliva had accumulated on his tongue that his dentist had to scrape off, so our son may have benefitted from the device to remove saliva. We also needed the cough assist and suction machine frequently, especially towards the end of his life.
I think the SWIK is not for everyone.
Nebulizer
Note: Our son used prescription medicines in conjunction with the nebulizer. Only the nebulizer’s mechanical aspects and issues are discussed here. The nebulizer’s medical aspects and issues are discussed in the Guide under the title https://guidetoals.com/mucus-and-medications/. As the mucus became thicker and more difficult to remove, our son’s doctor prescribed a nebulizer (see photo below; machine not included in photo). Initially, only albuterol (in water) was prescribed, but then N-acetylcysteine (NAC) was also prescribed. The NAC had to be used just prior to the albuterol. The nebulizer is a small quiet machine that is connected via a long flexible tube from a tiny reservoir holding the medicine to either a mouthpiece (for those that can hold the piece in the mouth), or to a simple mask (for those that cannot). The mask version is held loosely and gently with a simple rubber-band type strap; it doesn’t seal to the face like the cough assist mask does.
The nebulizer machine gently blows air through the medicine so that the vapors enter the mouth, or as in our son’s case, his nose and his mouth. The med was poured into a tiny reservoir that attached to the bottom of the mask (the green area in the photo below). The mask was comfortable on him. The nebulizer itself sat on a table near him. Just regular breathing was required when the nebulizer was in use. The mask quality we used (not the one pictured because I could not find it on the web) was so crappy and flimsy that the tubing connector between the mask and the chamber always cracked, so we always had to wrap it with tape to reinforce it. I kept telling the supplier about the cracking but I think they only had the one supplier.
The downside of the mask design was that the whole lower part of our son’s face became wet. The vapors didn’t just enter his nose and mouth. This med loosened the mucus so much that sometimes he didn’t want or need the cough assist afterwards. The problem was that the loosened fluids probably ran into his lungs.

https://www.atlantichp.com/nebulizer-mask-adult-32.html
VOCSN
VOCSN integrates five separate devices including a Ventilator, Oxygen concentrator, Cough assist, Suction, and Nebulizer into one multi-function device. Here’s a link to one supplier: https://www.reacthealth.com/product/vocsn-ventilator

Note: The Ventilator and Oxygen functions in the VOCSN assist with breathing, so they’re not discussed in this article; the other three functions, C, S, and N are for dealing with mucus and secretions. We had separate machines for suction, cough assist, ventilation, and nebulizer. Our son never used oxygen until the end of his life. The Millennium rep one day asked if our son (meaning WE) would like to try a VOCSN machine (on loan) because all the functions were in one device. We tried using it but returned it after only one day because it was a pain to use. Because we had to deal with our son’s frequent mucus, we always had to have our cough assist AND suction device running at the same time so we could switch back and forth quickly and frequently. However, with the VOCSN, we could only have one function running at a time. If we were using, let’s say, the cough assist function, but then needed the suction function, we had to go to the VOCSN touch screen, turn off the cough assist, switch to the suction function, wait for it to start, do some suction, then go back to the screen and switch back to the cough assist function, repeatedly. We had to change the associated hoses and equipment, too. We never even tried the ventilator or nebulizer functions. We returned the VOCSN.
Traveling with medical equipment
As our son’s ALS worsened, we had to take along his ventilator, cough assist, and suction device wherever we went. Using it in our van with the inverter was no problem. We just pulled off the road somewhere. I don’t think we ever had to use any of the devices while in motion.
We always had to bring this equipment into any and all buildings we entered in case we had to use them on our son. Many of the medical establishments we entered, like local doctors’ offices or DMEs (Durable Medical Equipment providers, like e.g., the Kessler Institute in West Orange, NJ) insisted that we had to use the devices in private, and out of view of other patients or customers, and in contained areas.
The cough assist and suction device were noisy and the procedures to use them were upsetting for others to see. We obviously needed a sink, drinkable water, and a toilet available for all this. The management of these places wanted us out of sight so as not to disturb other patients and customers. Using them out of sight also gave our son privacy. The management of these sites required us to go into store rooms, unused rooms, or mens’ rooms, which they told us they had to disinfect after we had finished.
In one appointment at the Kessler Institute that I mentioned above, our son needed the cough assist and suction device so extensively that day that we never made it to our appointment in that building and had to reschedule. We left without being seen by the specialist.